6/20/2005
United States Grand Prix, Indianapolis Motor
Speedway

I think this photo of Ralf Schumacher shortly
after his crash on Friday pretty much sums up the whole USGP 2005
experience for me.
I spent this past weekend in Indianapolis at the
Formula 1 U.S. Grand Prix. We were blessed with excellent weather
and exciting practice sessions. Unfortunately a series of Michelin
tire failures inflicted upon the Toyota team eventually turned the race
into the most incredible debacles in Formula 1 history.
During the second Friday practice, Ricardo Zonta
experienced a rear tire failure which put him into the gravel, then a few
minutes later Ralf Schumacher's tire failed and he crashed into the wall
in turn 13 and slid right in front of where we were sitting. Here's
a series of pictures that I shot during the crash:
Pictures of Ralf Schumacher Crash
In many of the pictures you can see the damage to
the left rear tire that failed. The crash was eerily reminiscent of
Ralf's crash last year in which he suffered a serious back injury.
The speedway installed a new barrier called a "Safer Barrier" which seemed
to be effective, since Ralf was able to walk away from the crash. It
was later announced that Ralf would not be participating in the race and
would be replaced by Zonta. Little did we know at the time that
there would be a multitude of other drivers that would not be
participating in the race.
On Saturday, rumors circulated that Michelin had
declared the tires unsafe for use during the race, and during the practice
before qualifying, all of the Michelin drivers were bypassing turn 13
altogether, instead driving through the pit road and back out on to the
circuit. It was said that Michelin was flying over a new set of
tires from France, and that they had petitioned the FIA to allow the teams
to switch to these tires without penalty. Qualifying continued
without incident, with Jarno Trulli capturing the pole position
(reportedly with an extremely light fuel load because of the importance of
the U.S. market to Toyota). Later in the afternoon we watched an
exciting Porsche Supercup race and an Infiniti Pro Series race in which
Marco Andretti (son of Michael, grandson of Mario) led from pole and won
easily.
On Saturday evening, we decided to go downtown for
dinner, and we ended up following a caravan of Ferrari mechanics to their
hotel. As we left the hotel, Rubens Barrichello and his entourage
passed right by us. We followed them down to an area where there
were many restaurants and ended up eating at a nice Japanese sushi
restaurant along with Juan Pablo Montoya and Kimi Räikkönen of
McLaren-Mercedes. It was quite an experience seeing these famous
drivers out on the town.
On Sunday morning, we arrived at the track in time
to watch the Porsche Supercup race, which would turn out to be the most
exciting race of the day. Because we were equipped with radio
scanners, we were able to listen in on the Speed TV radio chatter, and we
knew something was up long before many other fans in the crowd. It
was learned that the Michelin teams had requested that a chicane be
installed before turn 13 to slow the corner down. It was said that
they would not race unless this change was made. It was also said
that the FIA had denied the request and that there was some danger that
the FIA would withdraw from the race and remove it from the championship
and the teams might then race for show only. As we listened in
anticipation to find out what would happen with the tire situation, the
drivers were introduced and the cars were lined up on the grid. The
Speed TV announcers said that the teams were in a meeting and that they
were working to reach a compromise. For a moment it looked like race
might actually happen, but it was not meant to be.
The crowd was almost entirely caught off guard by
what happened next. The cars rolled off on their reconnaissance lap,
and as they completed the lap, all of the Michelin shod teams rolled into
the pits one by one. Some of the team mechanics looked as if they
were going to perform a pit stop, while other teams simply rolled their
cars back into the garages.
Only the six Bridgestone cars took the start, and
the race became a Bridgestone tire test with Ferrari taking a 1 - 2 finish
and moving them up to second place tie in the constructor's championship.
During the race, some unruly fans threw beer cans and water bottles onto
the racing surface, but I think overall the crowd was pretty restrained
given the circumstances. We retired to the motorhome shortly after
the beer cans started flying to watch the remainder of the race on Speed
TV via satellite.
As a fan, I was extremely disappointed with what
transpired, but I feel that the FIA has handled the situation
appropriately. It was entirely Michelin's fault for not bringing
suitable tires to the race. Changing the course to accommodate this
error would have been a dangerous precedent to set. Besides, had the
situation been reversed and the problem belonged to Bridgestone, I don't
doubt for a minute that the Michelin teams would have agreed to such a
change.
In the aftermath, I have read and heard many people
blaming the problem on Ferrari and their unwillingness to compromise and
their refusal to participate in the boycott. I think Ferrari,
Jordan, Minardi, and Bridgestone should be praised for getting out there
and running in the race as they were expected to do. I also agree
with the FIA's statement that the Michelin teams could have participated
in the race and used lower speeds in turn 13 as dictated by their inferior
tires, rather than turning the race into the debacle that it became.
The cost to the fans was great, and the damage to
Formula 1 in the United States may be irreparable.
Here are
some more photos we shot during the weekend.
|